59 pages • 1 hour read
A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Summary
Background
Chapter Summaries & Analyses
Key Figures
Themes
Index of Terms
Important Quotes
Essay Topics
Tools
Takeo Yoshikawa has spent the last three years studying English and learning everything about US Naval ships. His interceptions earned him a letter of gratitude from Adolf Hitler after his intel resulted in the sinking of several British ships. Yoshikawa is being sent under diplomatic cover to Hawaii, where he will monitor the US fleet and report through official channels: “‘If you want to deceive your enemy,’ [Yoshikawa’s superior] says, “you must first dupe yourself” (56).
Wada’s office, the 14th Naval District Intelligence Office, moves from the Federal Building to the Alexander Young Hotel. They are now only miles from Pearl Harbor’s Naval base. ONI now believe nearly every Japanese group or organization is run by the consulate, a vast, spy-infused network working toward the Japanese war effort. Official reports from the winter of 1941 reveal that the US was keenly aware of the Japanese Army’s (and intelligence apparatus’s) utilization of predominately Japanese groups in Hawaii to sow dissent, spread propaganda, and seek recruits for the Japanese cause. Realistically, most Japanese in Hawaii just wanted to wait out the war, causing harm to neither side.
Warrant Officer Theodore “Ted” Emanuel is tasked with capturing communications from Japan, assigned to Wada’s ONI. He is busy tapping the consulate phones, thinking about the linguist Denzel Carr and his assistant Douglas Wada, who will translate whatever his wire taps capture.
Captain Irving Mayfield arrives at the newly appointed head of the ONI’s 15th District Intelligence Office. His task is to monitor the Japanese consulate. His predecessor, Captain Hart, has moved to the fleet deck. Mayfield laments that there is no coordination between the various US intelligence agencies working on the “Japanese problem.”
Nagao Kita, the new Consul General at the Japanese Consulate, arrives in Hawaii in March of 1941. Upon arrival, he is added to the detention lists, should war ignite.
Takeo Yoshikawa arrives in Hawaii in March of 1941, assigned to the consulate under official diplomatic cover, though he is there for Army intelligence. He begins his work under the false name Tadashi Morimura. He is met by vice-consul Otojiro Okuda, who Yoshikawa instantly dislikes. Upon arriving at the consulate, he immediately meets Nagao Kita, the new consul general. His predecessor is tasked with being his assistant, a role Third Secretary Kokichi Seki finds humiliating. Further, he meets a driver named Masayuki Kotoshirodo, a local who can be discreet and helpful. The driver takes them to call the Naval ports, discusses the fleet’s movements, and helps direct them toward interesting waypoints. Yoshikawa likes the driver and is eager to ditch Seki.
Gero Iwai is an enlisted Army soldier in the Army Corps of Intelligence Police (CIP), the first Japanese American. He is discharged in April of 1941 and sent undercover to Hawaii to monitor the Japanese population and create detention lists. Unlike others in counterintelligence, Iwai believes the consulate holds the spies and that most Japanese-centric organizations are innocuous. His only friend is Douglas Wada, a counterpart who understands what it is like to live in a shadow between his heritage and his nationalism. Their friendship is profound and impactful, and they collaborate.
In Los Angeles in the summer of 1941, a young Japanese language student is arrested as a spy. Itaru Tachibana was a commander in the Japanese Imperial Navy. He ran a spy ring that included a British war hero named Frederick Rutland, Charlie Chaplin’s assistant named Toraichi Kono, and silent film star named Al Blake. After Kono attempts to recruit him, Blake, a former Naval officer himself, informs the US Navy. At the same time, Rutland is being sought by MI5, and both MI5 and the US Navy are working counterintelligence operations against Tachibana’s network.
With enough evidence, they arrest Kono, Tachibana, Blake, and Rutland, and although responsible for bringing down the network, Blake is nearly destroyed when the newspapers call him a traitor. Rutland is deported, the Japanese pay Tachibana’s bail, and Kono stays behind bars until the case is dropped. The American public is enraged by the spies among them, and the Japanese American population suffers scorn. Ringle, who has been working in LA, understands that the consulate lies at the heart of the spy networks. He firmly believes that the majority of the Japanese Americans in the US are loyal to the US.
Ringle decides to break into the consulate himself and enlists the help of a safe cracker from a nearby prison. He succeeds in getting a cache of intel and returns the prisoner to his cell before morning.
Wada tells Mayfield that the majority of the consulate calls are about the men trying to find sex workers and an affair between Kita and his maid. Washington still refuses to arrest consular officers, believing it will hurt Japanese American military recruitment and might endanger US diplomats abroad. Mayfield has finally convinced a cable company to tap the consular diplomatic cables, but this won’t take effect until December 1st, 1941.
At Tokyo High, the Nisei are Americanized and loyal to the United States, led by Japanese American leaders who meet with FBI Special Agent Shivers on security issues. Chief among them is respected attorney Masai Marumoto, who is by this time friends with Shivers. At a rally, more than 100 Nisei volunteer as reserve police officers and are trained by the force. Some enlist in the military. Others help take down Japanese signage and replace them with English. With these successes, Shivers hopes to demonstrate the potential for Japanese American loyalty to J. Edgar Hoover at the FBI.
General Walter Short is being reprimanded for his lack of war-time preparedness in Hawaii. Lt. Col. Burwell authors the report. Burwell is an investigator who was Shivers, Bricknell, and others aid in Hawaii’s intelligence. In response, Short lines up their planes wing-to-wing to prevent saboteurs from inflicting fleet-wide damage. Frustrated by poor, mixed communication out of Hawaii, Roosevelt puts the FBI in charge of coordination on the “Japanese Problem.”
FDR’s retreat from Washington to his summer home offers respite from the war. Japan has seized French Indochina. Roosevelt is prepared to seize all Japanese assets in the US; the text states: “It’s a drastic action that will cost Japan access to three-fourths of its overseas trade and 88 percent of its imported oil” (86). Amid rumors of the seizure, Issei withdraw funds, transfer titles, and panic. After the announcement, Japan sacks Saigon.
The US intercepts a Japanese military message to the Japanese consulate in Hawaii requesting information on the US Naval fleet at Pearl Harbor. The interception goes to DC but not to Hawaii.
Takeo Yoshikawa, under his false name Tadashi Morimura, joins the kendo club in Hawaii and attempts to befriend Americans who frequent the club.
Takeo Yoshikawa, under his false name Tadashi Morimura, sits at a tea house and watches the US Naval fleet. They are used to seeing him there, and he attempts to get intel from the geisha girls and staff. He has found a new driver and thoroughly understands the US Naval holdings on the island. By the end of November, the US Navy suspects a Japanese attack but does not suspect Hawaii. As a result, no defenses are strengthened in Oahu as a massive Japanese fleet bears down.
Takeo Yoshikawa is acting as courier for funds from Japan to a Nazi spy named Otto Kuehn, who is helping him monitor the Naval fleet in Hawaii. The Nazi’s two beach homes offer perfect vantage points and potential bases in the event of consulate closure. Kuehn’s 17-year-old daughter was Joseph Goebbels’s mistress, and Goebbels sent the entire family to Hawaii out of fear Hitler would retaliate against the girl for their affair. The whole family work as spies in the war effort. Although the FBI is aware of their activities and the transfer of funds, they cannot prove he is a spy. Kuehn devises a series of codes for the Japanese and agrees to offer his home and his skills when war ignites. Cables from Japan to the consulate increasingly demand intel on the US fleet.
Mayfield gets word the Japanese are burning confidential documents at the consulate, a sure sign that something big is coming. Both the FBI and the Navy believe the other is listening to consulate phones, but neither has taps. Nobody is aware of this oversight as word from DC confirms Japanese consulates around the US are burning documents. Although Mayfield’s cable tap is now active, with decipher and translation time it’ll be mid-December by the time he gets the first cables.
Shivers signs a report of 347 Issei names, those to be detained in the event of war. Hoover approves the list the next day and tells Shivers to ready the pickups (the list of those to be arrested). Meanwhile, Consul General Kita informs Japan that Pearl Harbor has limited defenses and no aerial surveillance or torpedo nets.
It is shortly after midnight on December 7 as two Japanese seamen in a sub approach Pearl Harbor. Using the maps and details from Yoshikawa, they approach the ships. The soldiers in one sub have a malfunctioning gyrocompass and can only tell their direction by surfacing. Still, they forge ahead toward Peal Harbor.
Although a work of narrative nonfiction, the book is written in the style of a spy thriller, complete with a quick pace, short chapters, and punchy dialogue. The authors end chapters at suspenseful moments, creating a page-turner effect. One notable example is the concluding line of Part 4’s “Alewa Heights” chapter, which ends with: “The carrier’s target is Oahu” (93). Dramatizations are interspersed between primary-source materials and direct quotes, while the setting and cast of characters are described in the style of the thriller. These authorial choices result in a book that reads like a thriller but offers fresh historical intelligence and analysis on the lead up to the attack on Pearl Harbor.
As in many spy thrillers, the real-world ONI and FBI operatives working ahead of the attack on Pearl Harbor were stymied more by a slow-moving bureaucracy than their adversaries, which highlights the theme of Organizational Failures and the Hard Work of Individuals in the Intelligence Services. The biggest dangers to their operations were interference from the machine of government or the slow-rolling of approvals. Operations were likewise endangered more by a lack of buy-in in DC than any opposition force. With the many roadblocks to operating effectively in Hawaii, the ONI and FBI sought ways to go around bureaucracy, ensuring the success of small missions in service to a greater cause. In many instances, the ends justified the means, even as operatives violated US laws in search of data and intelligence on their foe. The authors are careful not to comment on these repeated instances of bureaucratic roadblocks, but rather allow the preponderance of evidence, as delivered chapter after chapter, to paint a picture of a government ill prepared for war.
Ghosts of Honolulu: A Japanese Spy, A Japanese-American Spy Hunter, and the Untold Story of Pearl Harbor presents the US president as a multifaceted man capable of both victories and failures, boasting strengths and suffering weaknesses in his vital role. In the book, President Roosevelt is a visionary for assigning counterintelligence tasks ahead of the war and sending trusted experts to Hawaii to study the population. However, he then fails to value the reports that land on his desk as a result of these excursions: “The professionals are looking for sedition among the population and finding only a handful of foreign spies. Whether the politicians of the Roosevelt administration are listening to this fact is yet to be seen” (84). In another instance, the text depicts Roosevelt as clever for assigning intelligence tasks to multiple branches of the military and the federal government. But the book suggests that he is lacking in foresight when he fails to designate a lead agency responsible for coordinating the gathering of intelligence. Roosevelt’s mismanagement of the intelligence agencies coupled with his unwillingness to listen to agents’ reports results in dangerous miscommunications, wasted resources, and missed opportunities. By outlining these details, the book presents concrete information about how failures of leadership and bureaucracy stymied efforts to learn about and prevent the attack on Pearl Harbor.
Interestingly, the book does not explore the many actions the Roosevelt administration took in response to the war in Europe, including the Selective Service and Training Act of 1940 and the re-armament of the Armed Forces, both of which resulted in the United States being prepared for war in 1941. Ghosts of Honolulu: A Japanese Spy, A Japanese-American Spy Hunter, and the Untold Story of Pearl Harbor explores the espionage efforts in Hawaii before, during, and after the attack on Pearl Harbor and does not presume to explore WWII as a whole. However, the nation under Roosevelt was ready to respond to the attack. While Roosevelt’s failures in the intelligence arena were vast, he was astute in his estimation that war was inevitable and savvy in his mobilization efforts, the surprise attack on Pearl Harbor notwithstanding.
Throughout the book, the authors assume a basic understanding of the attack on Pearl Harbor, to great narrative effect. In Part 4’s “Fort Shafter” chapter, General Walter Short is reprimanded for Hawaii’s lack of war-time readiness. In response, the General orders the planes lined up wingtip to wingtip. Those with prior knowledge about the attack on Pearl Harbor understand what General Short does not, that his response will enable the destruction of a large part of the air fleet in Pearl Harbor in a devastating aerial attack. In fiction, this literary device is called dramatic irony. The reader is aware of vital information that the characters are not. In narrative nonfiction, this is used to great effect, because it gives the sense that past historical events are nonetheless unfolding on the page. Most of Parts 3 and 4 play off of this basic familiarity with the attack on Peal Harbor, minimizing the need for authorial commentary. Instead of this commentary, for example, the book presents the General’s perspective, showing that the action of lining up the planes is justified based on wide-spread paranoia of the “biggest risk stemming from ethnic Japanese living on the island” (84). The authors leverage this narrative about unjustified paranoia and racial bias by demonstrating the deviating impact of the paranoia and bias on American national security.
Plus, gain access to 8,800+ more expert-written Study Guides.
Including features: