63 pages • 2 hours read
A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
In recent years, William has been trying to establish his image as a modern, forward-looking royal. However, there is a growing divide between William’s public role and his personal life. For instance, he has spoken up about racism on the football pitch and called for more diversity in the BAFTA awards. Despite this, there has been no recorded conversation or reconciliation between William and Harry regarding Meghan’s experiences in the royal family.
William’s public persona took somewhat of a hit when rumors began circling regarding William’s role in Kate’s fallout with her ex-best friend, Rose Hanbury, the Marchioness of Cholmondeley. While there were suggestions that William and Rose’s closeness was the cause, the British media took a relatively tame approach to a potentially wild story, especially about how it has treated similar stories about other royals. The Palace worked overtime to ensure that the heir was protected. When the Rose Hanbury story first emerged, there was an uptick in negative stories about the Sussexes, which quickly silenced anything about William.
Throughout the entire episode, William kept his outward calm, resembling the Queen in this respect. He appears to have changed over the years—especially as he gets closer to the throne—turning colder and more indifferent. Scobie reflects on how the once pleasant William has turned less friendly, especially toward him, since Scobie’s professional relationship with the Sussexes began to grow stronger. Behind closed doors, however, William is very different from his persona. Reports are that he is short-tempered and difficult to handle, and this is also glimpsed in Harry’s recollections in Spare of William knocking him down in anger over Meghan’s behavior.
The rupture in William’s relationship with his brother is potentially a source of anger. He once spoke of a deep fraternal bond between him and Harry; their experiences growing up, including losing their mother, uniquely bonded the brothers for life. However, things began to change once Harry brought Meghan into their lives. William disapproved of her from the beginning; he considered her to be too much of an outsider, while Harry felt that William didn’t do enough to make Meghan feel welcome after their wedding. The tension in their relationship only escalated after Harry and Meghan split from the royalty and aired their grievances about the family publicly.
William’s stance on Harry taking on the British media offers another glimpse into his frustrations. At one point in his life, William was equally negative about the papers, but he has had to alter his approach because of the demands of his role. This integration of William into a “company man” has happened over many years. William was once criticized for being unwilling to focus on royal duties because he was doing considerably fewer engagements than other senior royals in the family. At that point, William’s priority was his family, and he and Kate set up a home in Anglesey, with William working a “day job” as an RAF pilot. He even extended his years in service by taking on a position with the East Anglian Air Ambulance charity in 2015, seemingly motivated by a desire to give his wife and children a relatively normal life.
William retired from his work as a pilot after coming under pressure from the public, the press, and the Firm in 2017. He moved into Kensington Palace and took on royal work full-time. Since then, he has seen a steady increase in his responsibilities, and he has been pushed further into the public eye. This has made him calmer and steadier, but also harsher and more indifferent, especially in his relationship with Harry. William does not agree with Harry’s views about the Firm anymore, and he believes that he has lost his brother forever.
The constant support William has received from the Firm throughout his life has, in part, driven a wedge between him and his father, as people view Charles as a transitional monarch. This has driven William to be a more involved and protective father to his children, to prevent the pattern from repeating. In the summer of 2022, William and his family left Kensington Palace and moved to Windsor, taking up residence in Adelaide Cottage on the property. This is an attempt at recreating the sense of normalcy that the family once had in Anglesey.
Scobie remembers a conversation he once had with William when the latter was still working as a pilot, where William confessed that after work he needed “to decompress...watch TV or have a cry” (198) before reentering the family space. Scobie was struck by the vulnerability of this admission, as it related to the heart of the royal dilemma: juggling a required life with a desired life. Scobie wonders if this side will ever be displayed again, or if it even exists so many years later. Based on how the Queen lived her life, and how William has been committing to his role in recent times, Scobie doesn’t think so.
After breaking away from the royal family in 2020, Harry and Meghan set up their lives in Montecito, California. The road there was a difficult one, littered with ruptured relationships as well as hasty deals and decisions to secure their finances. However, they believe this was the right decision due to the events that took place following their departure.
Harry and Meghan were in the UK for a series of engagements in September 2022 when the Queen passed. Beforehand, when the Queen’s health appeared to be in a critical state, Harry’s father had summoned him to Balmoral. As his brother refused to respond to his messages, Harry was forced to secure transport there on his own. As a result, he arrived much later than the rest of his family—and only after the public announcement about her death. Buckingham Palace refused to delay the announcement until Harry had been told personally.
There was minimal communication between the Palace and the Sussexes following the Queen’s death. Harry and Meghan were requested to be at a walkabout along with William and Kate at extremely short notice. Despite this and the acrimony between the two couples, the group nevertheless carried out their duties as consummate professionals. However, Harry had to fight the Palace to be allowed to wear his military uniform at a vigil organized for the Queen’s grandchildren, even though Andrew had been allowed to wear his full uniform at another vigil two days prior.
For a good portion of his life, Harry has been painted as a caricature of himself in the media, and for this reason, he is determined to win back his story. One of the ways he is attempting to do so is through his legal battles with various newspapers regarding both libel and illegal news-gathering. Because his family members don’t want to damage their relationships with the press, Harry was asked to drop the charges. However, he is determined to see the cases through and has joined forces with other celebrities to fight the papers. Harry views changing the media as his life’s work, particularly encouraging “the creation of a more ethical and reliable press” (215). Scobie discloses that he himself has testified in the Mirror News Group case, where, as a college intern he heard senior staff, including then editor-in-chief Piers Morgan, discuss phone hacking.
A few years following their departure from the royal family, the Sussexes' plate is full. They released Spare and their docuseries because they wanted to set the record straight, but they are now done with that chapter of their lives and are ready to move on. After their funding was abruptly cut off, they rushed to sign some deals to secure finances. A multimillion-dollar podcast deal with Spotify eventually fell through, and they still have no major anchoring projects for the foundation, Archewell. However, they are slowly finding their rhythm and working on projects close to their heart, including scripted projects for Netflix, charitable endeavors, and Meghan’s own business.
While Harry and Meghan are genuinely happier and closer than ever, some things still hurt, especially concerning their children. Upon the Queen’s passing, Archie and Lilibet should have automatically become “Prince” and “Princess.” However, it took the Palace six months to update the titles on the website, despite Wiliam’s and Kate’s titles having been updated in September 2022. Harry and Meghan see how their children are treated differently than the others. However, both have accepted that neither apology nor accountability may ever come from the royal family, and so are ready to move on.
The royal courtier’s work has not changed much from its predecessors’ roles in the 16th and 17th centuries. The job description is still to “diligently guide, protect, and serve their monarchs” (223), even if it means using deception and guile. Because of the nature of the work, the courtiers have earned many monikers. Harry referred to three specific courtiers as “The Bee. The Fly. And the Wasp” (224) in Spare. Princess Diana called them “the Men in Gray” (224), while Meghan and her friends referred to them as the “Palace Vipers.”
“Courtier” is a broad term that can refer to all sorts of palace aides. However, it is more commonly linked to press officials and private secretaries. Individuals in these roles walk a tight balance between being liked by their principals and being able to persuade them to do difficult things. They are responsible for reputation management of the royals and have played significant roles throughout important moments in history.
“The Bee” is Queen Elizabeth II’s former private secretary, Sir Edward Young. He was fiercely protective of the Queen, especially during the Harry and Meghan saga. Harry accused Young of gatekeeping the Queen from Harry. One opinion about Young is that he was an “uninspired” private secretary and partly responsible for the Harry and Meghan fiasco. Others believe him to be deeply committed to protecting the interests of the Crown.
“The Wasp” is Clive Alderman, Charles’s private secretary, who was instrumental in getting rid of Young’s predecessor, Lord Christoper Geidt. Geidt was accomplished and professional, and a great favorite of the Queen’s. He didn’t think that Charles had it in him to take over the reign from the Queen, so he actively blocked any chance of an early transition of power. With Andrew and Alderton’s help, Charles eventually managed to convince the Queen to replace Geidt with Young in 2017. Many in the family considered this the Queen’s biggest mistake, believing that Geidt could have better steered the family through the Sussex crisis.
Not all courtiers are manipulative and power-hungry; some are efficient, ethical, and universally well-liked. Samantha Cohen started in the communications department and eventually rose to be the Queen’s assistant private secretary. She filled in this role for Harry as well in 2018 and is credited with the success of the Sussexes’ 2018 tour of Australia, New Zealand, Fiji, and Tonga.
However, some courtiers enjoy getting involved in dishonorable activities, and Simon Case—“The Fly”—is a prime example. After having played secretary to more than one past prime minister (David Cameron, Theresa May), he was poached by William in 2018. Case saw the cracks in the relationship between William and Harry, and he used it to elevate William by recasting his image as the responsible and industrious one between the two. Despite several mistakes, William’s image was successfully established this way; however, the price was an irreparable wedge between the brothers.
Case eventually left the Palace and rejoined government service, working with Boris Johnson and later Rishi Sunak. He continued to be self-serving in these roles, too. During the “Partygate” scandal, Johnson claimed Case advised him that COVID protocol was being followed during the rule-breaking social gatherings held by Downing Street during the pandemic, but Case completely refuted these claims. Scobie notes that Case is a reminder of how “Svengalis” look to control and exploit. Relying on deception for image control may bring victory in the short run, but the truth will eventually come out.
Scobie profiles the brothers, William and Harry—with William, in particular—to exemplify the theme of Public Versus Personal Lives. Unlike his father, William has navigated this challenge more successfully. As he gets closer to the throne, he has become more adept at separating his public persona from his personal self. Despite his outward composure and relative unflappability, Scobie reveals that William is prone to bouts of temper behind closed doors.
While this separation is necessary, the sublimation of personal and public selves has additionally resulted in a colder, harsher William than before, as seen in his relationship with Harry. Over the years, the pressure on William to become a “company man” has seen him diverge in perspective from his brother to a fractious degree. He cannot afford the cognitive dissonance of seeing the flaws of the system and exist within it, too. Thus, over the years, William has altered a number of his personal beliefs and attitudes to match public demands.
William’s support for the system is also made easier because the Firm reciprocates the same, and this dynamic highlights the theme of Power and Image. Harry and Meghan’s experiences with the tabloids and the media suggested that the royal family could not and would not interfere with the journalists, for fear of retaliation or harming the relationship between the Firm and the media. In William’s case, however, the Palace has not shied from exerting pressure and influence to ensure that the heir’s image remains untainted. As a result, negative stories about William are not only scrubbed but also replaced by those about Harry.
Harry’s past use as someone deliberately sacrificed in the power plays by the Palace fuels his determination to win back control over his narrative. He has relentlessly taken on the media and pursued legal action against different media houses, and has willingly and publicly shared his side of the story. Harry and Meghan have separated from the royal family and are focused on pursuing their own lives outside of it. It is important for them to set the record straight, as they realize the power that image can hold, particularly in the royal context.
The royal courtiers are a set of important players within the institution. They have influenced important events that have shaped the current state of the monarchy, including the Sussexes’ split from the royal family. The workings of the courtiers display some of the grim realities of how the Firm works. There is ugly competition between different factions of the royal family, and a willingness to sacrifice relationships at the altar of power. Thus, Simon Case successfully rehabilitated William’s image into that of the more industrious and responsible brother, but did so utilizing and deepening the rift between William and Harry. The courtiers’ power and influence, seated in their responsibilities of reputation management, reinforces the complicated dynamics of and relationship between Power and Image within the royal family.
Plus, gain access to 8,800+ more expert-written Study Guides.
Including features:
British Literature
View Collection
Challenging Authority
View Collection
Class
View Collection
Class
View Collection
European History
View Collection
Family
View Collection
Inspiring Biographies
View Collection
Loyalty & Betrayal
View Collection
Politics & Government
View Collection
Power
View Collection
Sociology
View Collection
The Future
View Collection
The Past
View Collection
Truth & Lies
View Collection